Basically, with 7D (which stands, of course, for Seven Dwarfs), Disney are doing their version of The Smurfs.
Am I being too critical? Here's the trailer so you can judge for yourself:
The premise:
Described as a comedic take on the world of Seven Dwarfs in a contemporary storybook world, 7D takes place in Jollywood where Queen Delightful relies on the 7D — Happy, Bashful, Sleepy, Sneezy, Dopey, Grumpy and Doc — to keep the kingdom in order. Standing in their way are two laughably evil villains, Grim and Hildy Gloom, who plot to take over the kingdom by stealing the magical jewels in the 7D’s mine.It might be funny. People may think it's cute. I've heard positive things from people working there. And hey, to give credit where credit is due, after all the hideous things done to Mickey Mouse, the most recent property of Mickey Mouse shorts, in design, writing and sensibility, are rather brilliant. (Take a look HERE if you don't believe me.)
But why did they have to touch an already beloved (and, to put it in dollars, still highly marketable) set of characters, whom people still love seeing? It's not like these are, for example, the (thankfully) mostly-forgotten terrible Goons of Sleeping Beauty that are both a Disney property and untapped.
The show, standing on it's own legs, is likely to be either awful or pull an Adventure Time and be surprisingly great, (emphasis on the "surprisingly" here) but, at the risk of sounding like one of those "get off my lawn!" folk, either way the fairy tale connection appears to be pretty much teetering in at the zero mark. (You can see a whole post I wrote a while back on re-imagining Snow White's dwarves, from realism to OUAT to blockbusters and some very different illustrations, HERE.)
I guess we'll find out for sure on Monday, July 7th when it premieres.
(My sad face is on.)
Doesn't look like Smurfs to me. I grew up watching the Smurfs cartoon as a kid and have read a number of the Peyo Smurfs graphic novels as an adult. The comics are quite good and Peyo uses the Smurfs to satirize human behavior. As for this, well, I'm not sure what to make of it.
ReplyDeleteJudging by this post and the one you linked to, it seems we have similar views of the dwarfs. I always thought it was interesting that they saved Snow White's life a couple of times in the original story. They were more the heroes than the prince was. Also, if you take the dwarfs as human dwarfs (as in, people afflicted with dwarfism) rather than a mythical race, it kind of turns into a conflict between a queen who is vain, wicked, obsessed with traditional beauty and ultimately gorgeous and a kind group of outsiders who would have been considered funny looking at best and ugly at worst during those less enlightened times.